Parts Express pro stuff...

[clmrt]

Specifically,

http://www.partsexpress.com/pe/pshow...number=295-080


WinISD'd it against corrected E145 values. Seems a good clone, no?

Except for group delay...


*Flame suit on*

[Regis]

Mmmmm..... Took a look at the specs, the motor is only 109 ounces making it about 6.8 pounds. Kinda lightweight for a 15", doncha' think? The Xmax is only 6 mm, vs 7 mm for the E145 and while they claim it goes down to 36 hz, vs the 35 hz of the E145, it makes me wonder how the Parts Express woof performs against the 22 pound + motor of the E145. "...The E145 delivers pure bass notes at thunderous levels with the high efficiency and power capacity that musicians have come to expect from JBL loudspeakers...". The only caveat is if the motor in the Dayton is of the newer Neodymium type, thus the lower weight, but for $109 each, it makes me wonder. Maybe I'm wrong on all this and this speaker will actually perform just as well, but why are we all into JBL?


http://www.jblpro.com/pub/components/eseries.pdf

[Lancer]

*Flame suit on*

All transducers want to be a JBL when they grow up...

[Robh3606]

Might work but they are not the same. Overhung vs. Underhung coils as well as MM diferences. Just quessing these go lower but don't have the quickness of the 145's.

Rob

[Mr. Widget]

Might work but they are not the same....

The cones are different too... the E145 has a straight cone, the PE has a curvilinear cone.

They are simply different beasts. The PE may be decent... it may be more than decent.... or it may be crap. It will also depend on your application and expectations.

Widget

[clmrt]

This was more of a "hey lookit" kind of thing. If I had a friend in need, I'd have fun knocking together a big stupid 2-way or 3-way with these. Hack, of course, but hey.

[pelly3s]

The Dayton stuff is great for the money, actually great for a lot more money. I have worked with a lot of their stuff (mostly mids and tweets) but I didnt have experience building a sub with the Titanic MKII it was a single 12" box tuned to 28Hz, it could have gone lower but there wasnt much of a need. It did a great job when it came to shaking the house. My next project is actually going to be to build something with some Eminence Lab12's, I just got a pair of them so I am looking forward to that.

The woofer you have linked looks a lot like an Eminence frame, Im sure it gets plenty loud and sounds pretty damn good. The E145 is a very interesting speaker, and personally there arent too many woofers that i have heard that touch it.

[JBLnsince1959]

The E145 is a very interesting speaker, and personally there arent too many woofers that i have heard that touch it.

10-4

[bbrown]

If you are going to do something with a pair of LAB12s, there is a Tom Danley design that uses a pair. 41x41x18 inches. It will do 16Hz.

I can dig out the link on the patent app if you want. Very simple box too.

Bruce

[louped garouv]

pretty pretty please..... can we have it??? different from the LABhorn design? my understanding is that they are kinda tough to fabricate for a novice....


simple box sounds promising.....

[Rusnzha]

All transducers want to be a JBL when they grow up...

I built my first subwoofer using the Dayton PF-460-8, the 18 inch incarnation of PF-385-8. I used it for about a year so I had plenty of time to get to know it. I replaced it with a 2241H and the differences were immediately obvious. The Dayton matched the JBL in low end depth and impact. The subharmonics, however, from the 2241H sweetened the rest of my system in a way that seemed to go far beyond just changing a woofer. Also, certain problems went away after I made the switch. On the Dayton a note one step from another note could have a huge difference in volume. On the JBL, bass notes played at a consistant volume from one to the next. I paid 3 times as much for the 2241H. Was it worth it? You better believe it!

[pelly3s]

bbrown if you can get me that link that would be great. i dont have the time or the patience to build a labhorn. i was going to just go for the sono tube approach and see how it turned out. i had good luck with that and an Adire Shirva. There is just something about the LAB12 that is screaming tons of bass

[tomt]

Regis-- Mmmmm..... Took a look at the specs, the motor is only 109 ounces making it about 6.8 pounds. 22 pound + motor
`````````````````````````````````````````````````` ````````````````

is this just the magnet (109 ounces), not the motor?

[bbrown]

You need a special tiff viewer to look at the patent office site. I only have this in 24 separate files. As someone pointed out to me, you could probably build them for yourself and NOT get into trouble. Just don't try to sell them.

http://appft1.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-...DN/20040238268

Bruce

[Morgan Sloth]

here is the link to the tiff reader

http://www.bravaviewer.com/downloadreader.htm